Skip to main content

plagiarism in the pulpit

Joe Thorn put up the link to a disturbing piece of work by Steve Sjogren. He is a pastor in Cincinnati and the title of his article is Don’t be original – be effective!.*

The main point of the article is that pastors are spending too much time studying, praying and meditating in the production of crappy sermons. To be fair, he doesn't use the word crappy, but he does say,

"
Think about it for a second: If you really were giving a killer message each week, would your church be the size that it is right now? Maybe you need to be open to doing things a different way."

First of all, is giving a 'killer message' the ultimate goal in preaching? How do you give a killer message when teaching your people about suffering or the reality of what Jesus felt on the cross? Sermons on these subjects are not the kind of talks where people leave thinking 'Wow that preacher was amazing." And yet they must be taught.

In regards to a pastor's preparation to teach the Word of God Sjogren advises,

"First of all, stop all of this nonsense of spending 25 or 30 hours a week preparing to speak on the weekend."

Rather than spending time in prayer and asking God to reveal the truth of Biblical texts, a pastor should just search the web and find someone else's sermon on a topic or text. That cuts the message prep time way down.

But why would we not want to be original and speak God's fresh words to our people? Well, because, as Sjogren so intelligently tells us,

"[We need to get over the idea that we have to be completely original with our messages, each and every week.] In my mind there is a tremendous amount of pride (let's call it what it is) when we insist on being completely original as communicators."

We should steal, and copy and plagiarize other pastors material because if we think God would give us revelation and community/congregationally specific words we are flat out arrogant. To think that God would want me to say something other than what he has already given Rick Warren or Andy Stanley to say is prideful.

Come on Steve...do you really buy what you're writing here, or maybe you bought this piece from someone else and you're just passing it off as your work? You wouldn't want to be prideful would you?

*For an opposing viewpoint read Ray Van Neste's response
4 comments

Popular posts from this blog

5 Reasons I Won't Let My Kids Wear Clothes with Skulls on Them

Yesterday I threw out a poll question on my Facebook and Twitter pages.  The poll question asked, "Should Christians wear attire with skulls on it?"  I received some great comments from people with a variety of opinions.  You can read the comments on my timeline from 8/8/13.

My opinion is that Christians should not wear clothes with skulls on them.

I don't have one specific Bible verse that I can use to prove my point.  Jesus never said, "Thou shalt not wear clothes with skulls."  I do however think there are number of conclusions that can be drawn from Scripture that support my opinion.

1.  Jesus does care about the clothes we wear.
I don't believe God's people are free to wear whatever they want.  From the Old Testament all the way through the New Testament you can find Biblical language related to clothes.  There are laws in Leviticus about clothes.  God instructed the OT priests on what to wear don't believe God's people are free to wear wh…

How Stephanie and I Celebrated 15 Years of Marriage

Yesterday Stephanie and I celebrated 15 years of marriage! 
To kick off the festivities, on Wednesday afternoon Stephanie bought a new car from Harry Browns in Faribault. She said good goodbye to the minivan and bought a 2014 Dodge Journey. She picked out a great new vehicle and her dad Ralph channeled his inner New Yorker to haggle us a great price.
We started the day Thursday driving to St. Peter to pick up Isabelle from the "Gustie" Basketball and Leadership camp. She spent 4 days there learning, practicing and having a blast. We celebrated together as a family with some Godfather's Pizza!
After getting back to Northfield I dropped the kids off at some friend's houses so Stephanie and I could be alone together. Having great friends who help with the kids is such a blessing. 
Stephanie had the idea that we should get tattoos together. She didn't have to work hard to convince me! After asking for recommendations on Facebook we decided to check out  Guns and Nee…

How to Make an ISTJ Calm and Happy

When it is time to write a sermon I have found it is most effective for me to get out of the house and go to a coffee shop.  My mind is clearer and my focus is sharper there.  I am usually more productive.

The increase in output may be because, as pastor and author Mark Batterson often says, "change of place + change of pace = change in perspective."  However, I think something else is influencing me.  When I am out of my house I am not distracted by messes, dishes, house chores, or clutter; my mind is completely free to focus on the task I want to accomplish.

 In addition to Batterson's creativity axiom, here are a couple little formulas that I've found hold true for me:

Cleanliness = Creativity and Calmness.
Organized home = Organized mind.

Simply put, I function best when my environment feels under control.  This feeling of control comes in many different forms.  I feel like things are under control when my surroundings are clean and organized.  I feel like thin…