Skip to main content

Superstitious Spirituality

Been reading"What Got You Here, Won't Get You There" over the weekend. Great read with lots of stuff for me to think about and try and implement into my leadership; I'll review it more when finish.

One thing I read early in the book hit me from a spiritual perspective. In the book, Marshall Goldsmith discusses how successful people tend to fall into the trap of superstitious beliefs about their success. He defines superstition as,
the belief that a specific activity, followed by a positive reinforcement, is actually the cause of that positive reinforcement
I had a few crazy superstitions while I was playing hockey, and they are developed as the result of doing an activity and having success in the game, and then redoing that activity before the next game hoping for the same success. Some of my superstitions where: putting on equipment for my left side before my right, eating McDonald's on the way to the rink, listening to the same songs during warm-ups, taping my stick a certain way, and tucking in my jersey a certain way. I'm sure there were more. Point is, I did all those crazy things thinking they might have some effect on my success in the game.

Successful leaders can easily fall prey to the same superstition trap. The belief can sneak in that success was achieved because of a certain leadership behavior. Therefore, the leader repeats that same behavior over and over attributing their on-going success to the action being taken. Goldsmith rightly points out that, while there certainly are types of leadership behaviors that should be repeated, successful people must be careful that they don't forget some success is "in spite of" things rather than "because" of them.

I started thinking about this from a spiritual perspective. There is a tendency among Christians to attribute warm feelings towards God, or the experience of his blessing in our life, to a set of activities that we perform. Quickly, the superstitious mind set takes over and a person becomes trapped, repeating the same activity over and over again hoping for the same spiritual result. These activities take all kinds of forms:

- quiet time in the morning
- certain praise music
- addiction to retreats
- reading the same authors
- prayer w/ a special cloth or oil
- magical prayer words

What we have to realize is that we experience God in all kinds of ways, and sometimes we experience his blessing "in spite of" our behavior, not "because" of it. God is God, which means he is free to answer prayer, fill us with an out-pouring of his Spirit, heal, bring blessing, or manifest himself in all kinds of magnificent ways, without an superstitious beliefs among his people. Any positive spiritual reinforcement we get from an activity must be understood in the idea that God chose to act on his own, and we cannot expect a similar results simply by repeating that same activity another time. Doesn't mean we shouldn't repeat certain actions, we just shouldn't demand that God respond the same way each time.
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

5 Reasons I Won't Let My Kids Wear Clothes with Skulls on Them

Yesterday I threw out a poll question on my Facebook and Twitter pages.  The poll question asked, "Should Christians wear attire with skulls on it?"  I received some great comments from people with a variety of opinions.  You can read the comments on my timeline from 8/8/13.

My opinion is that Christians should not wear clothes with skulls on them.

I don't have one specific Bible verse that I can use to prove my point.  Jesus never said, "Thou shalt not wear clothes with skulls."  I do however think there are number of conclusions that can be drawn from Scripture that support my opinion.

1.  Jesus does care about the clothes we wear.
I don't believe God's people are free to wear whatever they want.  From the Old Testament all the way through the New Testament you can find Biblical language related to clothes.  There are laws in Leviticus about clothes.  God instructed the OT priests on what to wear don't believe God's people are free to wear wh…

How Stephanie and I Celebrated 15 Years of Marriage

Yesterday Stephanie and I celebrated 15 years of marriage! 
To kick off the festivities, on Wednesday afternoon Stephanie bought a new car from Harry Browns in Faribault. She said good goodbye to the minivan and bought a 2014 Dodge Journey. She picked out a great new vehicle and her dad Ralph channeled his inner New Yorker to haggle us a great price.
We started the day Thursday driving to St. Peter to pick up Isabelle from the "Gustie" Basketball and Leadership camp. She spent 4 days there learning, practicing and having a blast. We celebrated together as a family with some Godfather's Pizza!
After getting back to Northfield I dropped the kids off at some friend's houses so Stephanie and I could be alone together. Having great friends who help with the kids is such a blessing. 
Stephanie had the idea that we should get tattoos together. She didn't have to work hard to convince me! After asking for recommendations on Facebook we decided to check out  Guns and Nee…

Lessons from Mt Everest

It would be great is life was all fun and easy and exciting like glissading down a mountain side.  However life is actually much more like climbing up the mountain.  It is difficult, painful, dangerous and exhilarating all wrapped up into one.
Last Sunday I preached at a church in Northfield and I shared some thoughts about this.  I compared lessons I've learned studying mountain climbing to lessons I've learned living life.  Here are the five things I talked about, along with some accompanying Bible verses.
1. You have to have a goal and you have to work hard towards achieving it, sometimes for a long time ---> Jer 29:10-14  2. You have to expect setbacks (injury, weather, enemies, catastrophe) and roll with them ----> 2 Cor 4:8-10  3. You have to push yourself beyond what you thought possible ----> Phil 4:13  4. In most cases, you need others to help you (guides, logistics, cheerleaders, friends, expedition leader) ----> Heb 10:15   5. You have to acknowledg…