Skip to main content

The Case for Ethical Decision Making on Mt. Everest

Tonight I watched a documentary on YouTube called "The Dark Side of Everest." The film retells part of the story of the 1996 tragedy on the Mt. Everest where 11 people died. However the real focus of the film is on the ethical decisions people face when making choices about whether or not to help people on the mountain when they cannot help themselves.

What was interesting to me is the fact that many people kept referencing the idea of morals in regard to whether or not to help out someone who was sick or hurt. There was an underlying idea in many comments that people have a 'moral responsibility' to help out a fellow human being. What I want to know is where that responsibility comes from.

Obviously I have no idea about the religious ideology of the people interviewed in the documentary, but I have heard this kind of thinking before and when it comes from the mouths of atheists or agnostics it puzzles me. The ideas of evolution, natural selection and survival of the fittest have no finer theater in which to play themselves out than high up on a mountain. Right? If you're hurt that means your weak. And I should have no obligation to help you. In fact, my not helping only means that more strong genes will be passed on.

There are only morals if there is a standard by which to measure human behavior. There are only ethical decisions if there is behavior that is ultimately right and wrong. And there is only right and wrong behavior if there is an authoritative voice that declares it to be so. And that voice does not come out of any ideological, theological, or sociological hodgepodge. It comes from Jesus Christ, the Alpha and Omega, for whom and through whom all things were made and are held together by the word of his mouth.
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

5 Reasons I Won't Let My Kids Wear Clothes with Skulls on Them

Yesterday I threw out a poll question on my Facebook and Twitter pages.  The poll question asked, "Should Christians wear attire with skulls on it?"  I received some great comments from people with a variety of opinions.  You can read the comments on my timeline from 8/8/13.

My opinion is that Christians should not wear clothes with skulls on them.

I don't have one specific Bible verse that I can use to prove my point.  Jesus never said, "Thou shalt not wear clothes with skulls."  I do however think there are number of conclusions that can be drawn from Scripture that support my opinion.

1.  Jesus does care about the clothes we wear.
I don't believe God's people are free to wear whatever they want.  From the Old Testament all the way through the New Testament you can find Biblical language related to clothes.  There are laws in Leviticus about clothes.  God instructed the OT priests on what to wear don't believe God's people are free to wear wh…

How Stephanie and I Celebrated 15 Years of Marriage

Yesterday Stephanie and I celebrated 15 years of marriage! 
To kick off the festivities, on Wednesday afternoon Stephanie bought a new car from Harry Browns in Faribault. She said good goodbye to the minivan and bought a 2014 Dodge Journey. She picked out a great new vehicle and her dad Ralph channeled his inner New Yorker to haggle us a great price.
We started the day Thursday driving to St. Peter to pick up Isabelle from the "Gustie" Basketball and Leadership camp. She spent 4 days there learning, practicing and having a blast. We celebrated together as a family with some Godfather's Pizza!
After getting back to Northfield I dropped the kids off at some friend's houses so Stephanie and I could be alone together. Having great friends who help with the kids is such a blessing. 
Stephanie had the idea that we should get tattoos together. She didn't have to work hard to convince me! After asking for recommendations on Facebook we decided to check out  Guns and Nee…

Lessons from Mt Everest

It would be great is life was all fun and easy and exciting like glissading down a mountain side.  However life is actually much more like climbing up the mountain.  It is difficult, painful, dangerous and exhilarating all wrapped up into one.
Last Sunday I preached at a church in Northfield and I shared some thoughts about this.  I compared lessons I've learned studying mountain climbing to lessons I've learned living life.  Here are the five things I talked about, along with some accompanying Bible verses.
1. You have to have a goal and you have to work hard towards achieving it, sometimes for a long time ---> Jer 29:10-14  2. You have to expect setbacks (injury, weather, enemies, catastrophe) and roll with them ----> 2 Cor 4:8-10  3. You have to push yourself beyond what you thought possible ----> Phil 4:13  4. In most cases, you need others to help you (guides, logistics, cheerleaders, friends, expedition leader) ----> Heb 10:15   5. You have to acknowledg…